Soft vs. Hard Night Guards: Which One Is Better for You?

If you grind your teeth at night, a night guard is essential—but should you choose a soft or hard one? The right material depends on your grinding severity, comfort needs, and jaw health.

This guide compares:
✔ Pros and cons of soft vs. hard night guards
✔ Who each type is best for
✔ How to decide which one you need

Key Differences at a Glance

Soft Night Guards: Pros and Cons

✅ Pros:

• More comfortable for new users

• Less bulky, easier to sleep with

• Good for mild clenching

❌ Cons:

• Wears out faster (grinding can chew through soft material)

• Less protection for heavy grinders

• May encourage more grinding (some people subconsciously chew on them)

💡 Best for: First-time users, mild grinders, or those with TMJ sensitivity.*

Hard Night Guards: Pros and Cons

✅ Pros:

• Strongest protection against enamel wear

• Lasts years (not months)

• Discourages grinding (hard surface gives nothing to "chew" on)

❌ Cons:

• Takes longer to adjust to

• Slightly bulkier than soft guards

• May click if not fitted perfectly

💡 Best for: Severe grinders, people with tooth damage, or long-term users.*

Which One Should You Choose?

Pick a Soft Night Guard If You:

✔ Only grind occasionally
✔ Have TMJ pain and need a gentler option
✔ Want the easiest adjustment period

Pick a Hard Night Guard If You:

✔ Grind hard and frequently
✔ Already have worn-down or cracked teeth
✔ Want a long-lasting solution

What About Dual-Layer Night Guards?

A hybrid option combines:

• Hard outer shell (for durability)

• Soft inner layer (for comfort)

👍 Best of both worlds for moderate to severe grinders.

Final Verdict

• Soft = Comfort + Short-Term Use

• Hard = Protection + Long-Term Use

Still unsure? A dentist can help you decide—or try a dual-layer custom guard for balanced benefits.

FAQ

Q: Can I switch from soft to hard later?
A: Yes! Many start with soft, then upgrade if grinding worsens.

Q: Do hard night guards hurt?
A: They might feel odd at first, but shouldn’t cause pain. If they do, see your dentist for an adjustment.

Q: Are soft guards better for TMJ?
A: Sometimes—but a properly fitted hard guard can also help by preventing excessive jaw strain.

Need help choosing? Explore custom night guard options.

Also in Blogs